ModernBB or PunBB or Luna, which one is better?

Avatar

By ramtinak 8 July 2015 07:52

Member · 22 comments

Hi, I'm newbie in ModernBB or PunBB or Luna.
I was wondering to know, which one of these you suggest to install and use it as Forum?
Thanks alot


There is no easy way to understanding the life!

Windows/Phone Development Persian Training>
http://Win-Nevis.CoM

Avatar

By Vadim 9 July 2015 05:45

Member · 224 comments

Luna or phpBB 3.1


I do not understand the code. I am learning English.

Avatar

By __init__ 12 July 2015 20:10

Member · 40 comments

Luna.

Avatar

By rolfo 14 July 2015 18:00

Member · 86 comments

Poll function would be nice now  😋

>>> Luna <<<

Avatar

By Yannick 18 July 2015 06:57

Administrator · 1,390 comments

You're asking this on the Luna support forums? Luna of course. 😁 In general, you shouldn't be using ModernBB anyway as Luna can be considered "version 4".


You can do anything

Avatar

By Mohsen_Nirouzad 21 July 2015 15:48

Member · 134 comments

I used ModernBB, PunBB and Luna, I think they all are very great but
* PunBB isn't very beauty...
* Luna is new, And can has some bugs ...
* ModernBB is better, I personally use ModernBB

Luna.

Doesn't better write a reason too?

Last edited by Mohsen_Nirouzad (21 July 2015 15:59)


Sorry for bad English- I'm an English trainee | Sorry, maybe my codes incomplete or wrong, My PHP is poor ...
My email address

Avatar

By ramtinak 21 July 2015 16:16

Member · 22 comments
Mohsen_Nirouzad wrote

I used ModernBB, PunBB and Luna, I think they all are very great but
* PunBB isn't very beauty...
* Luna is new, And can has some bugs ...
* ModernBB is better, I personally use ModernBB

Luna.

Doesn't better write a reason too?

Here, See this>

http://getluna.org/features.php


There is no easy way to understanding the life!

Windows/Phone Development Persian Training>
http://Win-Nevis.CoM

Avatar

By Mohsen_Nirouzad 21 July 2015 16:26

Member · 134 comments
ramtinak wrote
Mohsen_Nirouzad wrote

I used ModernBB, PunBB and Luna, I think they all are very great but
* PunBB isn't very beauty...
* Luna is new, And can has some bugs ...
* ModernBB is better, I personally use ModernBB

Luna.

Doesn't better write a reason too?

Here, See this>

http://getluna.org/features.php

Oh, I didn't know it! I think I should emigrate to Luna, but... My biggest problem is restoring backups... Luna is really great and beautiful but if my problem doesn't solve, I must go to MyBB or ... Can you help me? I posted my question ...
Update: My problem solved, Thanks for good support! 😁

Last edited by Mohsen_Nirouzad (21 July 2015 16:33)


Sorry for bad English- I'm an English trainee | Sorry, maybe my codes incomplete or wrong, My PHP is poor ...
My email address

Avatar

By Yannick 21 July 2015 16:30

Administrator · 1,390 comments
Mohsen_Nirouzad wrote

I used ModernBB, PunBB and Luna, I think they all are very great but
* PunBB isn't very beauty...
* Luna is new, And can has some bugs ...
* ModernBB is better, I personally use ModernBB

Luna.

Doesn't better write a reason too?

Luna is indeed "new" in the sense that it got released back in April, however, like I said, its just a further developed version of ModernBB and could have been ModernBB 4, but we simply had to ditch the brand so we also started the versioning all over again.


You can do anything

Avatar

By Mohsen_Nirouzad 21 July 2015 16:35

Member · 134 comments

Thank you for your good support 😁


Sorry for bad English- I'm an English trainee | Sorry, maybe my codes incomplete or wrong, My PHP is poor ...
My email address

Avatar

By Vadim 21 July 2015 19:20

Member · 224 comments

I found engine SMF 2.1 Beta 2 ( example: simplemachines.ru )
Also good. By default there is embedded a Paid Subscription.

Last edited by Vadim (21 July 2015 19:27)


I do not understand the code. I am learning English.

Avatar

By rolfo 22 July 2015 17:45

Member · 86 comments

I used SMF for a few years. It was (and sure still is) a great peace of software. With some tweaks you can get nice results but the system is kinda 'out of date'. Don't get me wrong: smf is rock solid like phpbb 3 and i like the new features (like two-factor authentication - maybe an idea for luna?   😋  ) but the development is slow and the standard version with its customization possibilities needs a fresh, good looking, responsive rebuild.

That was the point why I came to ModernBB or now Luna  😁

Avatar

By Vadim 22 July 2015 18:24

Member · 224 comments

I agree with you! SMF development is slow.
But Yannick do not want to login with social. And he does not want to do Paid Subscription. 😩


I do not understand the code. I am learning English.

Avatar

By rolfo 23 July 2015 17:25

Member · 86 comments

Well if you really need it, then you should make a plugin for this purpose or use another forum software  😉

Avatar

By Mohsen_Nirouzad 24 July 2015 06:18

Member · 134 comments

Luna is really better than SMF, I analyzed SMF forums and Luna forums and I saw Luna's SEO is very better...


Sorry for bad English- I'm an English trainee | Sorry, maybe my codes incomplete or wrong, My PHP is poor ...
My email address

Avatar

By Vadim 24 July 2015 09:11

Member · 224 comments

You analyzed engine SMF 2.0.10 or SMF 2.1?
What forums do you analyze?
What's worse, what is better?

Consider please even the forums on the engine phpBB 3.1.
And write the details, and what is worse is better.

Thanks! 😁


I do not understand the code. I am learning English.

Avatar

By Mohsen_Nirouzad 25 July 2015 05:42

Member · 134 comments

Hi Vadim,
I bought a small host and uploaded SMF 2.0.10, Luna 1.1.1 and PHPBB ( I forgotten version, But it was the last version ) and I saw that Luna is better than SMF and PHPBB, website SEO analyzer wrote Luna is fast in loading and very good for mobile devices, Luna toke 46.66 percents and they both toke 33.33 percents.
I analyzed they with woorank

Last edited by Mohsen_Nirouzad (25 July 2015 08:01)


Sorry for bad English- I'm an English trainee | Sorry, maybe my codes incomplete or wrong, My PHP is poor ...
My email address

Avatar

By Vadim 27 July 2015 19:41

Member · 224 comments

I am test:
SMF 2.1 = 61.7% (http://bit.ly/1MsA0Gp)
phpBB 3.1.5 = 69.2% (http://bit.ly/1OwWWTo)
phpBB 3.1.5 = 76,9% (http://bit.ly/1ewzNUJ)
phpBB 3.1.5 = 63.2% (http://bit.ly/1IoR75Z)
Luna 1.2-alph = 50.6% (http://bit.ly/1fAQr6o)
Luna 1.1.1 = 42.1% (http://bit.ly/1SKRmxU)
Luna 1.1.1 = 42.5% (My Test Forum)
ModernBB 3.5.2 = 58.4% (http://bit.ly/1SbSoI9)

Last edited by Vadim (28 July 2015 13:15)


I do not understand the code. I am learning English.

Avatar

By Yannick 27 July 2015 20:13

Administrator · 1,390 comments

May I point out that for phpBB you're testing the front page of a community site and not an actual board.

Gotta love the way this test works, by the way. We get points of because we don't have @forum_getluna as our Twitter account.


You can do anything

Avatar

By Vadim 28 July 2015 12:43

Member · 224 comments

phpBB 3.1.5 = 76,9% (http://bit.ly/1ewzNUJ)


Personally, I do not like this test.
And I do not understand why we need to do this test.

Last edited by Vadim (28 July 2015 12:52)


I do not understand the code. I am learning English.

Avatar

By rolfo 28 July 2015 18:15

Member · 86 comments
Yannick wrote

We get points of because we don't have @forum_getluna as our Twitter account.

Gosh *facepalm*  😏